Meta has been hit with an €805 million ($887 million) fine in Italy after regulators found that Facebook accessed Android users' photos and videos without obtaining specific consent. The decision affects around 20 million users and gives Meta 60 days to change how the feature operates.
TL;DR
- Italy fined Meta €805 million ($887 million) over Facebook's access to Android users' photo galleries without specific consent.
- Around 20 million users in Italy were affected by a feature suggesting photos and videos for Facebook posts.
- Meta must disable the feature by default within 60 days and obtain separate consent. The company plans to appeal.
Italy Fines Meta Over Facebook's Access To Android Photo Galleries
A feature designed to make sharing photos easier has landed Meta in serious regulatory trouble.
According to the November 14 report, Italy's Data Protection Authority found that Facebook accessed photos and videos stored in Android users' phone galleries without adequately informing them or securing the necessary consent.
The issue centers on a Facebook feature that recommends images and videos from a user's personal gallery as potential posts.
While Facebook requested gallery access through a single app-wide authorization, the regulator found that the accompanying notice failed to clearly explain that the permission would also enable Facebook to generate content suggestions using those files.
Essentially, granting Facebook permission to access a phone's gallery did not necessarily mean users understood how their personal content would be used.
The regulator said approximately 20 million Android users in Italy were affected. The €805 million penalty, equivalent to about 0.47% of Meta's global revenue, ranks among the largest fines imposed on a technology company by an Italian authority.
Italy Orders Meta To Disable Facebook Photo Suggestions By Default
Alongside the financial penalty, Italian authorities have given Meta 60 days to disable the feature by default and introduce a separate consent mechanism.
The regulator also considered the continuing operation of the feature for users who had previously granted permission and those who had not updated their Facebook application.
Another factor was what the authority described as "Meta's lack of co-operation."
The investigation began in 2025, but notably did not examine whether Meta used the gallery content to train artificial intelligence models, a practice the company denied.
Meanwhile, the regulator has reserved the right to separately examine a feature introduced in 2026 that allows content from users' galleries to be processed in the cloud.
This adds another dimension to Meta's privacy challenges, particularly as the company has previously faced criticism surrounding photo usage, including its Muse Image feature involving public Instagram photos.
Topics For More Insights
- New Mexico Court Orders Meta To Pay $25 Billion Over Facebook Privacy Violations
- Meta Launches Muse Image, But Instagram Users Are Pushing Back Over Photo Reuse
- Meta Pulls Muse Image’s Public Instagram Feature After Privacy Backlash
- Meta Restarts Facial Recognition Tech While Clearview AI Can Identify From One Picture
Meta Challenges Italy's €805 Million Fine As US Privacy Penalties Mount
Meta has rejected the Italian regulator's findings and intends to appeal the decision.
A Meta spokesperson told the BBC that the company strongly disagreed with the authority's interpretation of the facts, its application of the law, and the size of the penalty.
"This is a straightforward feature which helps people post photos and videos to Facebook. People must give permission on their device before it can operate and they can change this permission at any time via their settings," the spokesperson said.
The Italian ruling also follows another substantial legal setback for Meta.
In October, a New Mexico judge ordered Meta to pay $25 billion following findings that it misled Facebook users about its data practices. Meta is also challenging that ruling.
For Meta, the Italian dispute now turns on whether an existing device permission provides sufficient consent for Facebook's specific use of personal photos and videos, an issue that could determine how the feature operates for millions of users.


